233k views
2 votes
Write an Argument Write an argumentative essay that answers the following question: Does Girard succeed in presenting a valid interpretati of Shakespeare's play Hamlet? Review your annotations and your respons the analysis questions before you begin .

User Landweber
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Girard successfully presents a valid interpretation of "Hamlet" by applying his mimetic theory to unravel the complexities of desire, rivalry, and tragedy in Shakespeare's play.

René Girard's interpretation of Shakespeare's play "Hamlet" is a compelling exploration that offers valuable insights into the dynamics of desire, rivalry, and violence. Girard's mimetic theory, which examines how human desires are shaped by imitation and competition, serves as a lens through which he views the characters' actions in "Hamlet."

Girard contends that Hamlet's tragic fate is intricately linked to the mimetic nature of desire, arguing that his internal conflicts and eventual downfall stem from imitating the actions of others. The theory provides a fresh perspective on Hamlet's character, revealing the complexity of human relationships and the destructive consequences of unchecked desires.

While some critics may challenge Girard's interpretation, asserting that it oversimplifies the multifaceted layers of "Hamlet," his analysis undeniably sheds light on the universality of mimetic desire and its impact on individual choices. Girard succeeds in presenting a valid interpretation by offering a unique framework through which audiences can view the intricate web of relationships and conflicts in Shakespeare's masterpiece.

In conclusion, Girard's interpretation of "Hamlet" enriches the understanding of the play by emphasizing the pervasive influence of mimetic desire. His argument contributes a valuable layer to the ongoing discourse surrounding one of Shakespeare's most enigmatic works.

User Shivam Aggarwal
by
8.9k points