40.3k views
3 votes
Divide statements into either Spontaneous Generation or Biogenesis:

A. Life can arise spontaneously from non living matter.
B. Microorganisms presentin nonliving matter can lead to new microorganisms.
C. Living cells can arise from nonliving matter under favorable conditions.
D. Vital forces in nonliving matter can lead to new life.
E. life can arise as a result of microorganisms present in nonliving matter.
F. Living cells can arise only from preexisting living cells.

User Jmlevick
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Statements A, C, and D are examples of Spontaneous Generation, a discredited theory suggesting life can originate from nonliving matter. Statements B, E, and F reflect the Biogenesis perspective, the scientifically supported theory that life comes only from preexisting life.

Step-by-step explanation:

Understanding the concept of where life comes from has been a significant point of debate in the scientific community for centuries. We can categorize the given statements into two historical scientific theories: Spontaneous Generation and Biogenesis. Let's divide them accordingly.

  • A: Life can arise spontaneously from nonliving matter. - This statement is the core concept of Spontaneous Generation.
  • C: Living cells can arise from nonliving matter under favorable conditions. - Again, this is a classic Spontaneous Generation view.
  • D: Vital forces in nonliving matter can lead to new life. - This is rooted in the ancient belief of vitalism, which is closely related to Spontaneous Generation.
  • B: Microorganisms present in nonliving matter can lead to new microorganisms. - Suggests microorganisms are responsible for the presence of new life, not spontaneous creation, thus aligning with Biogenesis.
  • E: Life can arise as a result of microorganisms present in nonliving matter. - This is similar to statement B and fits the Biogenesis theory.
  • F: Living cells can arise only from preexisting living cells. - This is the fundamental principle of Biogenesis, supported by scientific evidence like that of Louis Pasteur.

These categorizations reflect the historical shift from the discredited Spontaneous Generation to the widely accepted Biogenesis, which maintains that all life arises from existing life.

User Federico Taschin
by
9.1k points