165k views
5 votes
Why does a solid disk reach the bottom of an inclined plane rather than a hollow disk?

User Bjori
by
7.7k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The solid disk rolls down an inclined plane faster than a hollow disk due to its lower moment of inertia. Levers may have greater efficiency than inclined planes due to less energy waste. All solid cylinders roll down at the same rate on an incline due to uniform conversion of potential energy into kinetic energy.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question is concerned with the dynamics of how different shapes roll down an inclined plane due to gravity and rotational inertia. If two objects, such as a solid disk and a hollow disk, have the same mass and radius and roll down an incline, the solid disk will reach the bottom first. This is because the solid disk has a smaller moment of inertia compared to the hollow disk, meaning it requires less torque to achieve the same angular acceleration. In simple terms, the solid disk can start rolling more easily than the hollow disk. When considering cylinders rolling or sliding down inclines, if one cylinder rolls without slipping and the other slides without friction, they will reach the same height on another incline due to conservation of energy. However, the time taken for the rolling motion will be greater than for the sliding motion because rolling combines translational and rotational kinetic energy, leading to a slower translational speed.

When discussing the efficiency of simple machines like levers and inclined planes, efficiency is related to how smoothly and with how little energy waste an operation is performed. A lever might have greater efficiency than an inclined plane if it allows for less dissipative forces and a more direct transfer of energy.

In Galileo's experiments, it was found that all solid cylinders roll down an incline at the same rate, independent of their mass or size, because the mass m and radius R cancel out in the equation v = (gh)1/2. This uniformity in acceleration is due to the gravitational potential energy converting into both translational and rotational kinetic energy for rolling objects. A solid cylinder sliding without rolling would have a higher translational velocity at the bottom because all its potential energy converts into translational kinetic energy.

User Darek Kay
by
7.5k points