136k views
1 vote
Animals may make the best subjects for a research study for all the following reasons EXCEPT ______?

1) They have complex behaviors that can be studied
2) They can be easily controlled in a laboratory setting
3) They have similar physiological systems to humans
4) They can provide insights into human evolution and development

User Elodie
by
7.7k points

2 Answers

1 vote

Final answer:

Animals are key subjects in research studies due to their complex behaviors and similarities to humans, but being easily controlled in a lab setting is not a justified reason for their use, and ethical considerations must always be paramount.

Step-by-step explanation:

Animals are often used as subjects in research studies because they can provide valuable insights that are relevant to humans. However, there are certain considerations that must be taken into account when using animals for research. For example, one reason that may not justify using animals for research studies is that they can be easily controlled in a laboratory setting. While this may be practical for the researcher, it does not necessarily align with ethical standards or provide a benefit in terms of scientific investigation, especially if it involves subjecting animals to unnatural or stressful conditions which may affect the validity of the research.

Indeed, animals exhibit complex behaviors that can be studied, and they often have similar physiological systems to humans, which is why they make for fitting substitutes in research that would be unethical to conduct on humans. Furthermore, understanding animal behavior and their evolutionary development can offer insights into human evolution and development. Despite these advantages, it is crucial that all animal research is conducted under stringent ethical guidelines to ensure humane treatment, including minimizing pain and distress, and by obtaining approval from Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees (IACUC).

User PeteH
by
7.3k points
1 vote

Final answer:

Animals are often used in research because they exhibit complex behaviors, have similar physiological systems to humans, and can provide insights into human evolution. However, suggesting they are ideal subjects because they can be easily controlled in a lab overlooks the ethical implications and humane treatment required in animal research. The correct option that does not constitute a valid advantage of using animals in research is that 'They can be easily controlled in a laboratory setting'.

Step-by-step explanation:

Animals may make the best subjects for a research study for various reasons; however, one option from the list provided does not accurately represent a valid advantage. Animals do indeed exhibit complex behaviors that can provide valuable insights into their social structures and may even hint at the evolutionary patterns underlying human social behavior. In this sense, their complex behaviors can benefit scientific research significantly. Moreover, indeed, animals often have physiological systems similar to humans. This biological resemblance allows for the translation of research findings from animal models to human context, which is indispensable in fields such as medicine and psychology. Representing the shared ancestry and evolutionary trajectories, animals can indeed provide profound insights into human evolution and development, helping to elucidate our own species' history and biological changes over time.

However, the statement that animals can be easily controlled in a laboratory setting does not necessarily reflect a valid reason for why animals might make excellent research subjects. This view overlooks important ethical considerations that must be taken when conducting animal research. It is paramount to remember that while a controlled environment is beneficial for the consistency and reliability of experimental results, the well-being of the animals should always be a top priority. Ethical guidelines and institutional review processes, such as those enforced by Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees (IACUC), are in place to ensure that research involving animals is conducted responsibly, with minimal distress to the subjects. Researchers must design studies to minimize pain and distress, and facilities are subject to regular inspections for the humane treatment of animals.

When choosing any one option that does not constitute a valid reason for why animals may make the best subjects for research, the correct option to mention in the final answer is (2) They can be easily controlled in a laboratory setting, as it implies a disregard for the ethical treatment of animals in research. Effective animal research is not merely about control but ensuring ethical standards and humane treatment alongside scientific inquiry.

User Pavel Anossov
by
7.5k points