138k views
1 vote
Which of the following is not considered a likely solution to the question of why we are not currently aware of a galactic civilization?

A) There is no galactic civilization because civilizations are not common.
B) There is no galactic civilization because civilizations do not leave their home worlds.
C) The galactic civilization is deliberately avoiding contact with us.
D) The galactic civilization probably is undetectable to us because it makes use of technologies that do not obey the known laws of physics.
E) There is no galactic civilization because most civilizations destroy themselves before achieving interstellar travel.

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

Option D, which suggests galactic civilizations might use technologies beyond our understanding of physics, is not considered a likely explanation for the Fermi paradox. Other solutions include the rarity of intelligent life, self-destruction of civilizations before significant space travel, and a non-interventionist approach by advanced species.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question of why we are not currently aware of a galactic civilization despite the potential plentitude of life in the universe is known as the Fermi paradox.

The paradox revolves around the idea that if life and intelligent civilizations are common, there should be evidence of a galactic network, but none has been detected so far. Possible explanations include:

  • Intelligent life might be rare, even if simple life is common.
  • Civilizations might self-destruct before they can communicate or travel across the galaxy.
  • Technologically advanced civilizations might consciously choose not to interfere with less developed ones.
  • We might not have the technological capability to detect signals or signs of these civilizations if they employ means beyond our current understanding.

Among the options provided in the question, option D, which suggests that a galactic civilization probably is undetectable to us because it uses technologies that do not obey the known laws of physics, is not a commonly considered likely solution.

This is because most scientific speculation and SETI research are grounded in the physics we understand, leaving room for the possibility that our detection methods are limited but not that a civilization could entirely circumvent known physical laws.

User Ansgri
by
9.0k points