102k views
0 votes
Mr. Albertson is on the phone. He states his wife was in the clinic yesterday for lab testing and he wants you to tell him the results of the urinalysis immediately. You explain that his wife has individual privacy rights and such information can be disclosed only to her. You suggest he talk directly to her. He is very angry! “I have a right to know since I pay the bills. I’m going to report you for a HIPAA violation.” Question: Should you cave and tell him? Why?

User Olivie
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

No, the healthcare provider should not disclose the wife's urinalysis results to Mr. Albertson without her consent as it would violate HIPAA privacy rights. Issues of disclosure in cases of sexually transmitted diseases must be handled delicately, with healthcare providers encouraging patients to inform partners themselves or using anonymous notification systems. Cases involving minors require a balance between respecting the adolescent's confidentiality and ensuring their health and safety.

Step-by-step explanation:

Under the HIPAA guidelines, healthcare providers are required to protect patient confidentiality and disclose health information only to the individual unless consent is given for disclosure to others. In this case, you should not cave and tell Mr. Albertson his wife's urinalysis results because it would violate her privacy rights under HIPAA. Just because Mr. Albertson pays the bills does not give him the right to access his wife's protected health information without her consent.

When it comes to physician's duties regarding notifiable diseases, such as sexually transmitted diseases, there are public health exceptions where reporting is mandatory. However, these exceptions do not necessarily permit disclosure of patient information to sexual partners without consent. It would be best for the healthcare provider to address the matter directly with the patient, providing counseling and support to encourage the patient to inform at-risk partners themselves or utilizing anonymous notification systems when available.

In situations involving minors, healthcare providers must balance the desire to respect the adolescent's request for confidentiality with the need to protect their health. Providers often have protocols that prioritize the health and well-being of the minor while adhering to legal obligations. Parents' rights and minors' rights to confidentiality can vary by jurisdiction, and healthcare providers must navigate these complexities carefully, often guided by legal requirements and best practices for adolescent health care.

User Marco Stamazza
by
7.3k points