Question

Euripedes is a fictional student of Aristotle. following his teachers line of thought, he probably declares his commitment to civic association, but the true test of a person's worth is in what the individual does, not in personal characteristics. He fails to examine the fact that the principle of civic association excludes ______

Answer 1

Euripedes, following Aristotle's philosophy, would commit to civic association that emphasizes political participation and rational debate for the common good, but may overlook the exclusions in Aristotle's time based on property ownership and status.

Step-by-step explanation:

If Euripedes, a fictional student of Aristotle, followed his teacher’s line of thought, he would indeed declare his commitment to civic association, understanding humans as “political animals”. Aristotle emphasized that true human potential is fulfilled through active political participation and rational debate within a community, aiming towards the common good. However, if Euripedes fails to examine a principle of Aristotle’s philosophy, he might overlook the fact that, in Aristotle's time, the principle of civic association excludes non-property owning individuals, women, foreigners, and non-citizens. This exclusion contradicts the idea that every individual's actions contribute to their worth, as not all individuals had the opportunity to participate in Aristotle’s ideal governance, which favored a natural aristocracy of property-owning males born in the city-state.

Answer 2

Euripedes, a fictional student of Aristotle, likely declares his commitment to civic association and emphasizes the importance of individual actions over personal characteristics. However, he fails to examine the fact that the principle of civic association excludes arbitrary discrimination.

Step-by-step explanation:

Euripedes, as a fictional student of Aristotle, is expected to adhere to Aristotle's philosophical principles. Aristotle, known for his emphasis on civic association and the pursuit of the common good, valued the actions and virtues of individuals within the community. In declaring commitment to civic association, Euripedes aligns with Aristotle's teachings, emphasizing that a person's worth is demonstrated through their deeds and contributions to the community rather than inherent personal characteristics.

However, the statement suggests that Euripedes fails to critically examine the fact that the principle of civic association should exclude arbitrary discrimination. This highlights a potential blind spot in his understanding, as civic association should ideally be based on merit and virtue rather than prejudiced judgments.