204k views
5 votes
According to Hartmann, what is the 'degradation narrative'? How is it an example of or related to Malthusianism? According to Hartmann why has it proved particularly popular in Western policy circles?

a) The degradation narrative blames environmental degradation on overpopulation; It is related to Malthusianism as it aligns with population control measures
b) The degradation narrative emphasizes ecosystem decline due to industrialization; It is related to Malthusianism as it supports the idea of limited resources
c) The degradation narrative focuses on soil erosion and desertification; It is unrelated to Malthusianism and is popular due to its scientific basis
d) The degradation narrative promotes sustainable development; It is unrelated to Malthusianism and is popular for its emphasis on conservation

User CPerson
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

Hartmann defines the 'degradation narrative' as the belief that environmental degeneration is caused by overpopulation, thereby correlating it with Malthusianism. It is popular in Western policy circles due to its overlap with deep-seated economic and imperialistic interests.

Step-by-step explanation:

According to Hartmann, the 'degradation narrative' is a belief that environmental degradation is directly attributable to overpopulation. This narrative is indeed related to Malthusianism, as it shares the Malthusian concern with the limitations imposed by finite resources and the potential for unchecked population growth to exacerbate environmental issues. It aligns with Malthusianism in the sense that it suggests population control measures may be necessary to mitigate environmental decline.

Hartmann suggests this narrative has gained popularity in Western policy circles due to its alignment with longstanding Western economic interests and imperialistic motives. The West has historically been concerned with resource control and has often justified control over other regions through narratives that emphasize the need for management of resources, which has led to the imposition of population control measures in the global South.

User Travis Tubbs
by
7.8k points