217k views
0 votes
What are the issues with the Cisternal Maturation Model?

User Gokcand
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The Cisternal Maturation Model's limitations include its failure to consider DNA evidence and basing its conclusions on analogous traits that do not represent evolutionary relationships. It also does not account for cellular processes such as volume regulation before cell division, which has implications for understanding cell differentiation and the maturation zone.

Step-by-step explanation:

The issues with the Cisternal Maturation Model primarily relate to its inability to account for certain cellular and biological processes. Specifically, the model does not incorporate DNA evidence and is criticized for being based on analogous traits that do not accurately reflect evolutionary relationships. The model's limitations extend to not incorporating how cells measure total volume for regulation of expression at critical volumes, which according to the third model's claim should operate based on adding a constant volume before cell division to maintain homeostasis. This issue contributes to a broader discussion in biology regarding cellular systems, such as stem cell differentiation and development.

Moreover, when considering the broader context of the Big Bang Model, the question addresses some of the problems therein, such as the inability to explain why the universe's density is exactly at the critical density. This detail is essential as it impacts the universe's expansion rate and the potential for galaxy formation, thus touching upon cosmological questions about the conditions preceding the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) emission.

The issues raised indicate a need for more comprehensive models that can explain the complex phenomena occurring both at the cellular level and in the broader universe. These models should account for all evidences and mechanisms governing the processes of interest.

User Hsnbrg
by
8.0k points