125k views
5 votes
What does Hogan mean by the statement Dylan is simply following the golden rule? Is Hogan right? Why or why not?

a) Dylan follows ethical principles.
b) Dylan treats others as he wants to be treated.
c) Hogan is wrong; Dylan doesn't follow any rule.
d) Hogan is right; Dylan follows artistic principles.

User Gaurav Ram
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

Hogan's statement about Dylan following the golden rule likely refers to ethical behavior, and we need context on Dylan's actions to determine if it's accurate. Without such context, the claim cannot be definitively assessed.

Step-by-step explanation:

When Hogan refers to Dylan "simply following the golden rule," this likely means that Dylan is treating others as he would like to be treated himself. This principle is often mentioned in discussions about ethical behavior and moral principles. Philosophers, such as those mentioned in the provided text, discuss the complexities of applying moral rules in every situation, recognizing that while it is generally a good principle to follow, there can be exceptions and competing duties in certain scenarios.

However, without additional context specifically relating to Bob Dylan's actions or principles, it is not possible to definitively say if Hogan is right or wrong. If Dylan's actions are unknown, we cannot accurately assess whether he follows the golden rule or not. Assuming Hogan is referencing Dylan's commitment to his art and principles, then option d) Hogan is right; Dylan follows artistic principles might also be a valid interpretation, as the provided text indicates that both Bob Dylan and Leonard Cohen are unified by their integrity and devotion to their work.

User DrYak
by
7.8k points