69.5k views
2 votes
Decide if the following statement is true or false. Justify your conclusion with an explanation or counter-example, as appropriate:

"If S and T are subspaces and S∩T, then the [span of S∩T] = [span S] ∩ [span T]"

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The statement is false because the intersection of two subspaces S and T is not guaranteed to have the same span as the individual spans of S and T. An example using the x-axis and y-axis in R^2 helps to illustrate the discrepancy, demonstrating why the equation [span of S∩T] = [span S] ∩ [span T] does not hold true.

Step-by-step explanation:

The statement "If S and T are subspaces and S∩T, then the [span of S∩T] = [span S] ∩ [span T]" is false. Subspaces S and T are sets that themselves satisfy all the properties of a vector space, and their intersection S∩T is also a subspace.

However, the span of a set is the set of all linear combinations of its vectors. It's possible for S and T to have different vectors such that their spans are not equal, even though they might share some vectors in their intersection. A correct statement would be "the span of S∩T is a subspace of the intersection of the spans of S and T."

A counter-example would be taking S to be the x-axis in R^2 and T to be the y-axis. Their intersection S∩T is the origin {0}, which spans a subspace consisting only of the zero vector. However, the span of S is the entire x-axis and the span of T is the entire y-axis, and their intersection as spans is still only the zero vector, so the original statement is not valid because [span S] ∩ [span T] includes all possible vectors on both axes, which is far larger than the span of their intersection.

User Twilight
by
8.7k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.

9.4m questions

12.2m answers

Categories