185k views
0 votes
Compare and contrast Fest's and Huch's situations with that experienced by the defense plant worker. How do you account for the different choices they made? Can or should dissent be silent?

User Cabbagery
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

Fest's and Huch's situations can be compared and contrasted with that of the defense plant worker in terms of their choices and motivations. The different choices made by Fest, Huch, and the defense plant worker can be accounted for by their individual circumstances and beliefs. Dissent, whether silent or vocal, is an important aspect of a democratic society.

Step-by-step explanation:

Fest's and Huch's situations can be compared and contrasted with that of the defense plant worker in terms of their choices and motivations. Fest was a German citizen during World War II who chose to conform to the Nazi regime in order to protect his own safety and survival. Huch, on the other hand, was a German novelist who actively resisted the Nazi regime and expressed her dissent through her writings. The defense plant worker, in comparison, may have chosen to work in a defense plant due to economic and patriotic reasons, but may have also felt conflicted about the war effort.

The different choices made by Fest, Huch, and the defense plant worker can be accounted for by their individual circumstances and beliefs. Fest may have chosen to conform out of fear and self-preservation, while Huch may have felt a moral obligation to resist injustice. The defense plant worker may have chosen to work in a defense plant out of economic necessity or a sense of duty towards their country.

Dissent, whether silent or vocal, is an important aspect of a democratic society. It allows for different perspectives to be heard and can lead to positive change. However, the extent to which dissent can be silent depends on the context and the consequences of speaking out. In some situations, silence may be necessary for personal safety or to avoid retribution. However, in other situations, speaking out and expressing dissent openly may be more effective in challenging injustice and bringing about societal change.

User Adrian Holovaty
by
8.7k points