Final answer:
The statement is true; a good argument relies on reasonable and believable evidence. The strength of an argument comes from logical reasoning and the verifiability of its premises, which must be consistent with known truths and acceptable within the context of the field concerned.
Step-by-step explanation:
The statement that a good argument is determined by how reasonable and believable the evidence is can be considered true. A crucial aspect of a strong argument is the use of logical reasoning and empirical evidence to support the claims made. Logical assessment of an argument involves not just looking at the coherency and validity of the reasoning, but also critically evaluating the truthfulness and reliability of the premises.
An argument must be supported by evidence that is both sufficient and necessary for the claim. If an argument uses deductive reasoning, the conclusion necessarily follows if the premises are true. However, the strength of the argument is also dependent upon the truth of its premises, which can involve empirical facts, principles, or conceptual claims. When analyzing an argument, one must scrutinize the premises for factual accuracy, possible exceptions to principles, and the solidity of conceptual claims.
To construct a well-founded argument, both facts and inferences derived from them must be verifiable and consistent with other known truths. In fields as diverse as English literature or sociology, different types of evidence may be necessary to make a convincing argument. Therefore, understanding what constitutes acceptable evidence within a specific field is crucial for the argument's credibility.