Question

Desktop computers are a better option for students than laptops, which usually have less power and lower-resolution displays." Now, consider how someone might argue against this. Which sentence presents the strongest and most reasonable counterclaim to the above claim?

A) "Laptops are more portable and allow students to work and study from various locations, providing flexibility that desktop computers lack."
B) "Many modern laptops come with powerful processors and high-resolution displays, rivaling or even surpassing the capabilities of some desktop computers."
C) "Desktop computers are bulkier and take up more space, which can be impractical for students living in small dorm rooms or shared living spaces."
D) "Laptops are generally more energy-efficient than desktop computers, contributing to environmental sustainability and cost savings in the long run."

Answer 1

The strongest counterclaim to the idea that desktops are better than laptops for students is that many laptops now offer comparable or superior processor power and display quality.

Step-by-step explanation:

The strongest and most reasonable counterclaim to the claim that desktop computers are a better option for students than laptops due to power and resolution is: "Many modern laptops come with powerful processors and high-resolution displays, rivaling or even surpassing the capabilities of some desktop computers."

This statement provides a direct challenge to the original claim by highlighting that the technological advancements in laptop computers have significantly boosted their performance and display quality. Furthermore, it is factual that laptops offer incredible flexibility and portability, which are crucial for the dynamic learning environments students find themselves in today. As such, the notion that desktops are inherently superior due to performance and display specs is outdated and does not consider the diverse needs and scenarios of modern students.