221k views
4 votes
Which of the following examples best represents a precise claim?

A. "Having students wear uniforms impairs centers of the brain involved in non-linear cognizance, causing drastic declines in their ability to think and act outside the box when necessary."
B. "Another reason why students should not have to wear uniforms is because there is no direct evidence that they improve grades."
C. "Students should not have to wear uniforms to school."
D. "If that is not the case, then it is pointless to force students to spend time and money wearing these clothes."

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

Option A represents the most precise claim, stating a specific cause and effect relationship regarding the impact of school uniforms on students' cognitive abilities, which makes it testable and debatable.

Step-by-step explanation:

When considering the options provided, we must evaluate each for precision in expressing a claim. A precise claim is detailed, specific, and testable. Option A offers a very specific claim regarding the impact of school uniforms on non-linear cognizance. This statement includes a cause (school uniforms), an effect (impairs centers of the brain involved in non-linear cognizance), and a further effect on students' thinking abilities.

In contrast, options B, C, and D are not as precise. Option B states there is no evidence but fails to specify conditions or effects. Option C is a broad, generalized statement of opinion without any supporting details. Option D provides a conditional, vaguer sentiment that could be dependent on multiple interpretations.

Based on the examples provided in questions, claims that students come to school with poor habits of mind and the importance of not believing something solely due to the absence of evidence against it, we can ascertain that a more specific and evidence-based claim adds to the credibility of an argument, much like Option A offers a specific, test-provoking claim that can potentially be challenged and tested.

User Farhan Farooqui
by
8.1k points