61.9k views
1 vote
Freud's theories are considered controversial and influential. Do you agree with Freud's theories?

A) Yes.
B) No.

User Saranda
by
7.4k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

Freud's theories, while criticized for their lack of testability, are influential in introducing the study of the unconscious mind and emphasizing early childhood's role in later life. His work paved the way for neo-Freudians and various psychological practices that consider unconscious influences on behavior.

Step-by-step explanation:

While Sigmund Freud's theories are indeed controversial and have been criticized and questioned for their scientific validity, they have undeniably been influential in psychology. Freud, a medical doctor due to the lack of psychology degrees during his time, was a pioneer in exploring the unconscious mind. He was the first to systematically delve into its workings, a concept widely embraced in psychological thinking even today.

The major criticism of Freud's theories lies in their lack of testability, leading to a challenge in the empirical validation of his ideas—such as the psychosexual stages of development and the partitioning of the mind into id, ego, and superego. Despite this, Freud's contributions cannot be dismissed. His emphasis on early experiences' formative role and the unconscious's prevalence has laid the groundwork for modern psychology.

Many therapists still believe in the concept of the unconscious and its impact on our conscious behaviors and emotional responses. Freud's ideas about repressed memories, defense mechanisms, and internal conflicts have found their way into various aspects of psychological practice, such as developmental psychology, personality theory, and therapeutic approaches.

Following Freud, neo-Freudians like Adler, Erikson, Jung, and Horney built upon his foundational ideas but also revised them significantly. They introduced new concepts to psychology, such as the inferiority complex, collective unconscious, and archetypes, and challenged some of Freud's more biologically driven assumptions, instead of considering broader sociocultural influences.

User Harshit Laddha
by
7.5k points