Question

Perhaps you wanted pizza for dinner, but were outvoted by the rest of the family who wanted chili. This is similar to what happens in a community. One person has to give up a right for the good of the group. Sometimes citizens' duties and rights conflict with each other. A good example is a public protest. People have the right to meet in groups and share ideas. However, a protest can disrupt traffic or other normal activities. A city must provide extra police protection to keep people safe. Therefore, the city has the right to require permission in advance for a protest. Government must make laws to balance the rights of individuals and different groups of people. Which of the following statements best describes this paragraph?

a) The paragraph describes the purpose of laws in a community but lacks the use of any text connections.
b) The paragraph describes a simple comparison between a family protest and a community protest.
c) The paragraph uses categories of comparison to judge whether individual or group rights are most important.
d) The paragraph uses the analogy of a family is to choosing dinner as a community is to balancing rights and safety.

Answer 1

The paragraph describes how laws in a community balance individual rights with societal duties, using a family dinner scenario as an analogy for community decisions, and the best answer is d) The paragraph uses the analogy of a family is to choosing dinner as a community is to balancing rights and safety.

Step-by-step explanation:

The paragraph provided delves into the complex interplay between individual rights and societal duties, using the scenario of a family deciding on dinner as an analogy for how a community balances the needs and wants of its members. It underscores the role of government in creating laws to achieve this balance, exemplified by the regulation of public protests to ensure both the right to assembly and public safety are upheld. When a city requires permission for a protest, it does so to maintain order and protect citizens, echoing the social responsibility and governmental duties described by political philosophers like John Locke and Jean Jacques Rousseau, who advocated for a social contract.

The best description of the paragraph is d) The paragraph uses the analogy of a family is to choosing dinner as a community is to balancing rights and safety, as it discusses how laws and regulations serve to mediate between individual freedom and the common good, with specific reference to the right to protest versus the need for public order.