158k views
1 vote
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of introducing 'golden rice' crops.

a) Increased vitamin A content, resistance to pests
b) High yield, environmental concerns
c) Improved taste, low nutritional value
d) Resistance to diseases, high production cost

User Jackson J
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Golden Rice offers increased vitamin A content and resistance to pests, potentially improving health and reducing pesticide use. Its yield compared to non-GM rice is variable, and it represents higher production costs. The advantages must be balanced with environmental concerns and the complexity of integrating GM crops into agricultural systems.

Step-by-step explanation:

Advantages and Disadvantages of Introducing 'Golden Rice'

Golden Rice is a genetically modified (GM) crop developed to contain increased levels of vitamin A. This fortification is designed to combat vitamin A deficiency, which is a significant health problem in many parts of the world. The main advantages of Golden Rice are its increased vitamin A content and potential resistance to pests, which may lead to improved health outcomes and reduced agricultural losses. On the other hand, the disadvantages include environmental concerns, such as potential impacts on biodiversity and the risk of gene flow to non-GM crops, and the high production cost associated with the development and regulation of GM crops.

When comparing the yield of Golden Rice to existing rice varieties, studies have shown mixed results. Some suggest the yield is comparable, while others indicate a reduction in yield due to the resources needed to produce the added nutrients. As for resistance to infestation, like many GM crops, Golden Rice may offer increased protection against certain pests, reducing the need for pesticides. In terms of nutritional value, Golden Rice significantly surpasses conventional rice by providing a potent source of vitamin A.

The decision to grow and sell Golden Rice commercially weighs the potential health benefits against economic, environmental, and ethical considerations. While Golden Rice offers a solution to a specific nutrition problem, it is just one tool among many that agriculturists can use. Its success depends on the acceptance by farmers, governments, and consumers, as well as the outcomes of ongoing discussions regarding GM crop safety and environmental impact.

User Resander
by
7.2k points