11.0k views
3 votes
Of the following criteria, which is the best to use in evaluation of informational literature for children?

1) credentials of the author
2) documentation through footnotes and reference lists
3) complete coverage of the topic
4) scholarly writing style
5) accuracy of information and a strong narrative arc

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The correct answer is option 5) accuracy of information and a strong narrative arc.

Step-by-step explanation:

When evaluating informational literature for children, it's critical to focus on several aspects to ensure the material is high-quality and reliable. Of the given criteria, accuracy of information and a strong narrative arc are particularly crucial because they ensure that the content is factual and engaging for the audience. The credentials of the author also play a significant role, as they contribute to the credibility of the information presented. When considering other evaluation factors, one might look at the timeliness of research, relevance to subject, and potential biases of the author.

To judge credibility, begin by checking the author's expertise and whether they have a background that's relevant to the subject. For instance, a well-known scientist writing about a scientific topic likely provides more reliable information than an amateur. Also, examine whether the information has undergone peer review, which can substantiate the accuracy of the content.

Moreover, additional elements worth considering include a scholarly writing style, complete topic coverage, and the presence of documentation through footnotes and reference lists. While these elements are important, they might be less critical for children's literature compared to the readability and engagement factor provided by a narrative arc and clearly presented, correct information.

Lastly, evaluate the materials for any bias or slant that may influence the content's presentation and ensure that a diversity of perspectives is considered.

User Nick Ragaz
by
7.9k points