5.7k views
2 votes
What is the irony of Ross' response when Macduff asks about his wife and children in Scotland?

User Ginnie
by
7.0k points

2 Answers

2 votes

Final answer:

Ross's response to Macduff is ironically reassuring, despite Ross knowing the truth about the murder of Macduff's family, creating dramatic irony.

Step-by-step explanation:

The irony of Ross's response when Macduff asks about his wife and children in Scotland lies in the way Ross provides a soothing, hopeful message to Macduff despite knowing the tragic truth - that Macduff's family has been brutally murdered.

This is dramatic irony because the audience is already aware of the dire situation, but Macduff is not. Ross tries to protect Macduff from the heartbreak for a little longer by not revealing the true extent of the horrors committed by Macbeth's orders against Macduff's family.

This moment showcases the theme of deceit and the painful impact of false hopes.

User Nissan
by
7.6k points
5 votes

Final Answer:

The irony of Ross' response to Macduff about his wife and children in Scotland is that Ross initially evades the truth and provides misleading information, stating that Macduff's family is well when, in reality, they have been brutally murdered on Macbeth's orders.

Explanation:

The irony in Ross' response lies in the stark contrast between his words and the tragic reality of Macduff's family. When Macduff, devastated by the news of his family's fate, inquires about their well-being, Ross deliberately skirts the truth, offering a misleading reassurance. This creates a dramatic irony for the audience, as they are aware of the brutal murders ordered by Macbeth, making Ross' seemingly comforting words a poignant betrayal of the truth.

Ross' choice to withhold the painful reality from Macduff adds depth to the unfolding tragedy. The audience witnesses the unfolding tragedy with a sense of foreknowledge, intensifying the emotional impact of Macduff's eventual discovery. The irony in Ross' response serves as a narrative device, heightening the tension and emphasizing the tragic consequences of Macbeth's ruthless pursuit of power. Overall, Ross' deceptive reply underscores the pervasive atmosphere of deceit and manipulation within the play, contributing to its themes of betrayal and the corrupting influence of unchecked ambition.

User Esteban Brenes
by
7.8k points