124k views
1 vote
Who Can Replace a Man?

User Gaggina
by
7.2k points

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

The question 'Who Can Replace a Man?' opens a discussion about gender roles, employment, and societal expectations in the context of historical and literary perspectives. It underlines the tensions between traditional gender norms and the advancement of women in the workforce, particularly when men's comfort or the maintenance of 'natural' roles is perceived as being at risk.

Step-by-step explanation:

The query 'Who Can Replace a Man?' touches upon themes of gender roles, employment, and social norms. It seems to question the proposition of replacing male workers with female workers and whether societal views on gender should dictate employment, especially in the context of post-war labor dynamics. Historical perspectives combined with literary references from Seneca the Younger and Agnes Macphail suggest a critique of gender bias and the perceived threat of female advancement to male comfort.

Agnes Macphail's quote highlights the discomfort some men may feel at the prospect of women advancing, while the LibreTexts reference to the 1946 survey indicates a time when societal preference for male employment was clear, despite efficiency. The notion that if women became self-sufficient, the question arose: 'what will the men do then?' illustrates the gendered division of labor and dependence that existed historically. However, as the quote from the respondent's sister Sara indicates, women have the potential to reject their subordinate status by taking up roles traditionally filled by men. In literature, Martial's epigram suggests a paradox where men might act contrary to nature, just like when societal expectations for gender roles are questioned.

User CyberCat
by
7.7k points