Final answer:
The question deals with the philosophical concept of identity through change, using the Ship of Theseus paradox. It asks whether a band remains the same once all original members have been replaced. By considering the spatiotemporal continuity view, one could argue that identity persists through continuity in actions and branding, outweighing objections that solely focus on the original components.
Step-by-step explanation:
The question "Are they still Theseus band after all original members have been replaced?" invokes a classic philosophical puzzle known as the Ship of Theseus, which explores the nature of identity over time and through change. This is often discussed within the subject of metaphysics, a branch of philosophy. When applying this paradox to Theseus's band, we must decide what, fundamentally, makes this band itself.
If we determine identity by the continuity of the members, then, once all original members have been replaced, it is no longer the same band. Conversely, if we define the band's identity through other factors, such as its name, style, fan base, or contractual obligations, then one could argue the band's identity has persisted despite the change in membership.
One Solution: The Spatiotemporal Continuity View
One solution proposed in metaphysical discussions is the spatiotemporal continuity view. This theory posits that as long as there is continuity in space and time—for instance if the band consistently performs, produces music, and maintains its name and style—the band's identity endures. The strengths of this view are that it accommodates gradual change and reflects how we often perceive entities in the real world.
This view might outweigh objections based on the necessity for original members, because it considers the broader context of the band's existence and operations, discounting the strict requirement for original components.