Final answer:
The contradiction between bond-breaking requiring energy and catabolic pathways releasing energy is resolved by the fact that energy stored in bonds is released when new bonds are formed with products of lower free energy than reactants.
Step-by-step explanation:
When considering the apparent contradiction between bond-breaking requiring energy and catabolic pathways releasing energy, the reconciliation lies in the fact that energy stored in bonds is released when new bonds are formed with products of lower free energy than reactants.
This is option D. During catabolic reactions, certain chemical bonds are broken and new ones are formed. Bond-breaking requires an input of energy, but this energy is subsequently released when new bonds are formed with products that have lower free energy. Therefore, the overall energy change favors energy release despite the energy requirement for bond-breaking.