219k views
3 votes
If gravity is mediated by a spin two field in which negative masses attract, how can the Schwarzchild solution with negative mass repel a negative mass test particle?

User Yessica
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The repulsion of a negative mass test particle by a Schwarzschild solution with negative mass is a result of the theoretical spacetime geometry surrounding a hypothetical negative mass, which differs from the attraction of gravity in Newtonian mechanics.

Step-by-step explanation:

If gravity is mediated by a spin two field in which negative masses attract, the question arises about how the Schwarzschild solution with negative mass repels a negative mass test particle. In general relativity, the Schwarzschild solution describes the gravitational field outside a spherical non-rotating mass. For a black hole, it describes the spacetime geometry around it, including the event horizon, which is defined by the Schwarzschild radius (Rs). The concept of negative mass is hypothetical and does not have a direct observational counterpart in physics. While general relativity allows for a Schwarzschild solution with negative mass, this is generally considered to be a mathematical peculiarity rather than a physical possibility. In the Schwarzschild solution with a negative mass, spacetime curves repulsively, and a negative mass test particle would be repelled due to this spacetime geometry.

It's important to understand the distinction between gravitational force in Newtonian mechanics and the concept of spacetime curvature in general relativity. While the former describes gravity as a force attracting masses, the latter explains gravity as a result of masses curving spacetime. When discussing quantum mechanics, we also have to consider the creation of particle-antiparticle pairs in black hole environments, which involves gravity and energy considerations, though this is more related to Hawking radiation and quantum field theory than to the classical treatment of negative masses. In conclusion, the Schwarzschild solution with negative mass leading to the repulsion of a negative mass test particle is a result of the exotic spacetime geometry that a negative mass would theoretically produce, which differs fundamentally from the attraction behavior of gravity as typically understood.

User Gallagher
by
7.7k points