Question

Does modern physics state that air molecules can randomly whizz around in such a way to cause a voice emanating from the clouds that is clear and coherent?Is this possible or not? Is this extremely improbable or is it possible?

The motivation of the question comes from Dawkins where he talks about how a human statue could theoretically move in a way that doesn’t contradict the laws of physics. He just says it is incomprehensibly improbable.
Which is correct?

Answer 1

According to modern physics, it is not possible for air molecules to randomly cause a voice emanating from the clouds. The probability of this event occurring is extremely low.

Step-by-step explanation:

Can air molecules randomly cause a voice emanating from the clouds?

According to modern physics, it is not possible for air molecules to randomly cause a clear and coherent voice emanating from the clouds. The phenomenon of sound requires a medium, such as air, to transmit the vibrations from a source to our ears. In the case of a voice emanating from the clouds, there would need to be a specific source, such as a speaker or an organism capable of producing voice-like sounds.

While it is true that extraordinary events could happen due to the unpredictable nature of quantum mechanics, the probability of air molecules randomly forming a voice in the clouds is extremely low, bordering on being incomprehensibly improbable.