Question

Is determinism compatible with moral culpability? Why or why not?

a) Yes, determinism completely negates moral culpability.
b) No, determinism doesn’t absolve moral culpability entirely.
c) Determinism doesn't affect moral culpability.
d) Determinism and moral culpability are unrelated concepts.

Answer 1

Determinism and moral culpability are not completely unrelated concepts. Incompatibilists argue that determinism undermines moral culpability, while compatibilists argue that they are compatible.

Step-by-step explanation:

Determinism and moral culpability are not completely unrelated concepts. However, determinism does present challenges to the concept of moral culpability.

Incompatibilists argue that determinism undermines moral culpability. They claim that if our actions are determined by external forces, then we cannot be held morally responsible for our actions, as we lack true freedom and control over them.

On the other hand, compatibilists argue that determinism and moral culpability are compatible. They propose that even if our actions are determined, we can still be morally culpable if we act in accordance with our own desires and intentions, and if we have the ability to act differently under different circumstances.