89.0k views
5 votes
What is a commander communicating to subordinates and superiors when a commander approves a waiver?

User Sep Roland
by
7.8k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

A commander approving a waiver signifies their ability to adapt or modify policies within their scope of authority. This highlights the intricacies of military hierarchy and the balance of power within the chain of command, demonstrating command discretion and decision-making in response to unique situations.

Step-by-step explanation:

When a commander approves a waiver, they are essentially communicating a modification or exception to standard policy or procedure to their subordinates and superiors. This act indicates a level of discretion and authority possessed by the commander, allowing them to adapt or bypass certain requirements for a deemed necessary purpose. The fact that a commander has this power highlights the importance of command discretion and hierarchical decision-making within military and governmental structures, as well as the balance between following orders and adapting to situational needs. By approving a waiver, a commander may be responding to unique circumstances that require flexibility, and this action can have significant implications for operational effectiveness and morale.

In historical contexts, such as the relief of General MacArthur, it's clear that the maintenance of the military hierarchy and adherence to civilian control are critical to the functioning of American military and executive powers. The President's role as commander-in-chief, as detailed in the Constitution, asserts their ultimate military authority, which includes hiring and firing of military commanders and occasionally requires the president to make tough decisions when these commanders act outside the chain of command or in an insubordinate manner.

User Zack Bloom
by
8.4k points