150k views
5 votes
US Supreme Court Decision Washington v Harper 1990, the right to refuse treatment is limited for prison inmates because:

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The right to refuse treatment for prison inmates is limited due to the need to balance individual rights with the government's responsibilities, including managing prison safety, security, and health concerns.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the US Supreme Court Decision Washington v. Harper (1990), the right to refuse treatment is limited for prison inmates because the courts balance individual rights with the government's need to govern and provide for the common good. This includes managing the safety and security of the prison environment and maintaining order. In certain situations, the Supreme Court has ruled that the government should provide healthcare to prisoners, indicating that while the right to refuse treatment exists, it can be overridden for reasons such as the orderly management of prisons and safeguarding the health of the inmate population. This is consistent with other decisions such as Hamdi v. Rumsfeld and Boumediene v. Bush, where due process rights and habeas corpus rights are affirmed, but also delineated under specific contexts like national security and enemy combatants.

User Tayyab
by
8.0k points