In Guy de Maupassant's "Was It a Dream?" and Edgar Allan Poe's "Annabel Lee," the narrators' tones are similar, conveying sadness and longing. Language choices such as descriptive phrases contribute to these tones. If told from the perspective of the deceased female characters, the tones would be different, such as more serene or filled with love and devotion.
Step-by-step explanation:
The short story mentioned in the question is Guy de Maupassant's "Was It a Dream?" which tells the story of a distraught man who visits the grave of his deceased lover and makes a shocking discovery. The poem mentioned is "Annabel Lee" by Edgar Allan Poe, which is a romantic poem about the death of the narrator's beloved.
The tones of both narrators are similar as they convey a sense of sadness, melancholy, and longing. The language choices made by the authors contribute to these tones. For example, in "Was It a Dream?", the narrator uses phrases like "desperate grief," "hopeless longing," and "crushing agony" to create a tone of deep sorrow. In "Annabel Lee", the narrator's tone is conveyed through words and phrases such as "sepulchre," "seraphs," and "kingdom by the sea," which evoke a sense of mourning and loss.
The tone of each of these texts would be different if told from the perspective of the deceased female characters. In "Was It a Dream?", if the story was told from the perspective of the deceased lover, the tone might be more peaceful or serene, since she is already at rest in death. In "Annabel Lee", if the poem was told from the perspective of Annabel Lee, the tone might be filled with love and devotion, as she reflects on her connection with the narrator even in death.