5.0k views
3 votes
When the Code of Ethics and state law conflict, law takes precedence.

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

When a professional organization's Code of Ethics conflicts with state law, the state law takes precedence due to the hierarchy of legal authority established by the US Constitution. Professional codes regulate behavior but do not have the same authority as legally enacted state laws.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student's question addresses the interaction between a professional organization's Code of Ethics and state law. When situations arise where these guidelines conflict, it is essential to understand that there is a hierarchy of legal authority within the United States. According to Article VI of the Constitution, the Constitution is the supreme law of the land, holding precedence over all other forms of law. This hierarchy is as follows: the Constitution, federal treaties, federal laws, state constitutions, state laws, and then local ordinances. Therefore, when a conflict arises between a Code of Ethics and state law, the state law takes precedence because ethical codes are not legally binding in the same way that laws are. Professional codes are essential for regulating behavior within a profession but do not have the same legal authority as laws enacted by governmental bodies.

Moreover, professional organizations in various fields, such as the American Sociological Association or the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers Computer Society (IEEE-CS), establish ethical codes which their members are expected to adhere to. These standards are designed to ensure responsible conduct; however, when a state law contradicts these ethical standards, professionals are legally obligated to follow the law, as per the supremacy of the law.

The Constitution not only holds the federal government to its principles via the rule of law, but also ensures that these principles are unfailingly applied throughout the nation, creating a unified legal framework that guides both governance and the operation of professional practices. Consequently, individuals and professional entities must comply with the law above any professional code of ethics.

User DoneForAiur
by
8.4k points