65.9k views
2 votes
Jonathan, a fifteen-year-old, yells at his neighbor, Rhys, for playing loud music through the night. In response, Rhys yells at Jonathan and pushes him to the ground. In the context of Freud's structures of personality, which of the following structures most likely dictated Rhys's behavior in this scenario?

a) Ego

b) Superego

c) Id

d) Unconscious Mind

User Scharette
by
7.0k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Rhys's behavior of yelling and pushing Jonathan is most likely governed by the id, which seeks immediate gratification of primitive urges, without the balancing influence of the ego or the moral guidance of the superego.

Step-by-step explanation:

The behavior of Rhys in this scenario is most likely dictated by the id.

The id is a component of Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory of personality, which comprises our most primitive drives and desires. It operates on the pleasure principle, seeking immediate gratification without considering the repercussions of actions. In contrast, the ego aligns with the reality principle, striving to satisfy the id's desires in a realistic and socially acceptable manner. The superego, which develops through social interactions, is responsible for upholding moral standards and striving for perfection, often leading to feelings of guilt or inadequacy when those standards are not met.

In the given situation, Rhys's aggressive response of yelling back and physically pushing Jonathan appears to be an impulsive act driven by the desire for immediate satisfaction of his urge to retaliate, characteristic of the id's operation. It suggests that Rhys's ego was unable to mediate between his primitive impulse and more reasoned response, and the superego's role in governing behavior through moral conscience was seemingly overpowered or absent in the heat of the moment.

User Wiwiweb
by
7.9k points