145k views
4 votes
Water is necessary for life. Diamonds are not. Is the marginal benefit of an additional glass of water greater or lesser than an additional one-carat diamond? Why?

User Arik
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The marginal benefit of an additional glass of water is lower than that of a one-carat diamond for individuals who have sufficient water, because water is necessary for life and widely available, while diamonds are rare and hold high economic value. This is known as the diamond-water paradox. However, potable water can be scarce globally, which can affect its perceived benefit.

Step-by-step explanation:

When considering the marginal benefit of an additional glass of water compared to an additional one-carat diamond, it's essential to understand the context. Water is essential for life and is critical for various cellular processes. However, for someone who has plenty of water, the marginal benefit of an additional glass may be low. In contrast, diamonds are not necessary for survival but possess high market value. Therefore, if a person is well-hydrated, the marginal benefit of an additional one-carat diamond might be greater due to its rarity and the value society places on it.

Water's importance to life cannot be overstated. It comprises about 60-70 percent of the human body and is required for the production of food, energy, and other mineral resources. Yet, because water is so abundant and essential, it has a phenomenon known as the 'paradox of value' or 'diamond-water paradox,' where essential items like water might have low marginal benefit in well-supplied situations, while non-essential items like diamonds can have a high marginal benefit because of their rarity and desirability.

Interestingly, only 4 percent of the total water on Earth is freshwater, with 68 percent of that locked in glaciers. Access to drinking water continues to be a critical issue globally. Despite the abundance of water, its distribution and the availability of fresh, potable water make it a scarce resource in many communities.

User Aurand
by
8.0k points