121k views
3 votes
Which of these choices is a disadvantage of the Endangered Species Act?

a) Promotes conservation of endangered species
b) Facilitates extermination of dangerous animals
c) Supports biodiversity conservation
d) Encourages habitat protection

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

The disadvantages of the Endangered Species Act include the difficulty in listing species, implementation challenges for management plans, a skewed focus on individual species, underfunding, and legal complexities with private lands. A more incentive-based approach might be more effective than the act's current command-and-control strategy.

Step-by-step explanation:

The disadvantage of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) among the choices provided is not explicitly listed. However, considering the provided information and the intent of the question, which seems to be about the shortcomings of the ESA, we can infer that the disadvantages are related to the challenges the act faces. One of the key criticisms of the ESA is the difficulty in getting a species listed and the subsequent challenge of implementing effective management plans. Additionally, there is sometimes a focus on individual species at the expense of others, potential controversy over delisting species, underfunding and understaffing issues, and the complexity of extending legal protection to private lands.

Furthermore, while fines and jail sentences can deter harmful activities, they can also incentivize counterproductive behaviors, like landowners altering their property to avoid restrictions. As such, a balanced environmental law that includes incentives for private landowners to protect habitats may offer more promise than a strict command-and-control approach. The ESA is also critiqued for protecting individual species rather than entire ecosystems, which can be inefficient and leave other species unprotected.

User Andy Zhang
by
7.7k points