62.6k views
3 votes
The major objection to the straight-line method is that it assumes the asset's economic usefulness and maintenance repair expense are the same each year.

t
f

User Zilongqiu
by
8.3k points

1 Answer

0 votes

Final answer:

The straight-line depreciation method simplifies the calculation of an asset's depreciation by assuming equal value loss annually, but it might not accurately reflect real economic usefulness or maintenance costs. Firms with continuous operation face increasing maintenance expenses over time. Similarly, a straight-line PPF is a simplification indicating constant opportunity costs, contrasting with the more realistic outward-bending PPF displaying increasing costs.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student's question touches on a concept in accounting, specifically related to the straight-line method of depreciation. The straight-line depreciation method assumes that an asset will lose the same value each year over its useful life, which is a simplification for calculation purposes. However, it's often pointed out that this assumption may not accurately reflect an asset's actual pattern of economic usefulness or the repair and maintenance costs incurred; these expenses can fluctuate and generally increase over the asset's useful life.

Considering different types of firms, some may have relatively low fixed costs and thus could be less affected by the inaccuracies of straight-line depreciation. However, firms with more significant fixed assets might find that maintenance costs increase over time. For example, if a manufacturing plant operates continuously without routine maintenance due to high production demands, they could face increasing marginal costs as equipment wear and the need for repairs grow.

In the context of economics, a related concept is the production possibility frontier (PPF), which can be straight or outward-bending. A straight-line PPF indicates constant opportunity costs, which is a simplification and less realistic. In real-world scenarios, as production of one good increases and another decreases, opportunity costs usually increase, represented by an outward-bending PPF.

User Pancakes
by
8.3k points