Final answer:
The thesis sentence for a paragraph describing the tones in the scene after George kills Lennie in 'Of Mice and Men' could be: 'The tone of George in this scene is one of sorrow and regret, while Curley and Carlson display a mix of shock, anger, and indifference. This contrast in tone emphasizes the complexity of the situation and highlights the different emotional reactions to the tragic event.'
Step-by-step explanation:
A solid thesis sentence for an analysis of tone in the scene after George kills Lennie in Of Mice and Men could be: The contrasting tones of resignation and insensitivity in the aftermath of Lennie's death underscore the novel's broader themes of companionship and the callousness of the world.
George's tone is one of silent sorrow and resignation, whereas Curley and Carlson's tones are detached and insensitive, highlighting the lack of understanding and compassion among the ranch hands. The scene's tone, conveyed through their reactions and dialogue, emphasizes the profound loneliness and inevitable tragedy embedded within the human condition.
This is evident through the stark difference in George's withdrawn and quiet demeanor contrasted with Curley and Carlson's emotionless view of the event, which links back to Garrison's thesis on the isolating effects of society on individuals.