218k views
3 votes
When are you allowed to carry out emergency treatment/transport of a CAPABLE patient without consent?

a. When the patient is unconscious.
b. When the patient's family requests it.
c. When there's immediate danger to the patient.
d. When the patient refuses treatment.

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

Emergency treatment or transport of a capable patient without consent is only permissible in cases of immediate danger and patient incapacity to consent. Living wills and advanced directives, including DNRs, are critical in guiding decisions when the patient cannot express their wishes. State laws and hospital policies also play a significant role in such determinations.

Step-by-step explanation:

Emergency medical treatment or transport of a capable patient without consent is only permissible in a situation where the patient is incapable of giving consent and there's immediate danger to the patient's life or health (implied consent). Therefore, none of the options provided (a-d) would be correct if the patient is capable of making decisions. The legal and ethical standards in the medical field usually require patient consent before treatment or transport can be initiated. Exceptions to this principle occur if the patient lacks decision-making capacity, such as being unconscious, or in rare cases where public health is at risk.

For instance, decisions surrounding medical response to patients declared brain dead are complex and often involve consideration of the patient's prior wishes such as a living will or advanced directive. Advanced directives, including Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders, help to guide medical personnel in such situations. These documents express the patient's preferences concerning medical treatment when they are no longer able to communicate their wishes themselves. In scenarios where family members are making decisions on behalf of a patient, state laws and hospital policies can significantly impact the actions that are taken, especially in ethically complex situations like the ones noted in the brain-dead cases mentioned.

User Tei
by
7.3k points