36.9k views
1 vote
Hartnup vs. Vitamin B3 deficiency

a) Similar symptoms but different causes
b) Identical manifestations with the same etiology
c) No relation between the two
d) Vitamin B3 deficiency causes Hartnup disease

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Hartnup disease and Vitamin B3 deficiency present with similar symptoms, including pellegra-like dermatitis and mental changes, but have different causes; the former is genetic while the latter is typically dietary.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question addresses the similarities and differences between Hartnup disease and Vitamin B3 deficiency. Hartnup disease is a rare metabolic disorder characterized by defective transport of certain amino acids including tryptophan, which can result in a secondary niacin (Vitamin B3) deficiency because tryptophan is needed to synthesize niacin. As a result, individuals with Hartnup disease may exhibit symptoms similar to pellagra, which is caused by niacin deficiency itself. These symptoms include a dermatitis known as pellegra-rash, diarrhea, dementia, and if left untreated, the condition may lead to death.

Therefore, the correct answer to the question is (a) Similar symptoms but different causes. Hartnup disease is caused by a genetic defect affecting amino acid transport, and niacin deficiency is usually due to poor diet. Despite their different causes, they can share similar clinical presentations.

User Ivan Kvyatkovskiy
by
8.6k points