148k views
2 votes
When you are speaking with a child’s parent, they say I was spanked and I turned out fine. It’s not a big deal. How should you respond?

User Weirdgyn
by
7.0k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

In response to a parent's comment on spanking, present research that indicates spanking can lead to negative outcomes like aggression and emphasize modern reinforcement strategies over physical punishment.

Step-by-step explanation:

When a parent mentions that they were spanked as a child and they turned out fine, it opens a discussion on physical discipline and its implications. Despite the approval rating of spanking by some in the United States, research and the positions of many psychologists and parenting experts suggest caution. Your response could focus on modern approaches to discipline, such as positive reinforcement over punishment, and the potential negative effects of spanking, which studies have found can lead to increased aggression in children, especially if used at a young age. Furthermore, cultural and educational backgrounds can influence attitudes towards physical punishment, with variations observed across different regions and education levels. Respectfully sharing this knowledge could provide an opportunity for a more informed and constructive conversation on child discipline.

"According to studies, spanking is not an effective form of punishment and can result in adverse outcomes like increased aggression in children, particularly when used on very young children. In fact, reinforcement is favored over punishment in contemporary psychology, where rewarding positive behavior is recommended."

User Gbanfill
by
7.5k points