Question

Parris says that "there is either obedience or the church will burn like hell is burning. This is an example of a logical

fallacy. This is an Either/Or or False Dilemma fallacy. This is a logical fallacy because it assumes that there are only
two possible choices when in fact there are other choices available. What are some other choices?

Answer 1

A false dichotomy fallacy occurs when a limited number of possibilities are assumed to be the only available options. In this case, Parris is presenting a false either/or dilemma by suggesting that the only options are obedience or the church burning. However, there are other choices available such as questioning Parris's authority, proposing alternative solutions, and exploring different consequences.

Step-by-step explanation:

A false dichotomy fallacy occurs when a limited number of possibilities are assumed to be the only available options. In this case, Parris is presenting a false either/or dilemma by suggesting that the only options are obedience or the church burning. However, there are other choices available:

1. Questioning Parris's authority and demanding evidence to support his claims.
2. Proposing alternative solutions or compromises that promote both obedience and a peaceful resolution.
3. Suggesting that disobedience may not lead to the church burning and exploring other consequences.

By recognizing the limitations of the either/or fallacy, we can consider additional options and engage in a more nuanced discussion.