Question

If a pt (in their right mind), directly states their wishes to their physician then those wishes carry {more or less weight?} than a written document.

a. More weight
b. Less weight
c. Equal weight
d. No weight

Answer 1

A patient's verbal instructions generally have less weight than a written document such as a living will or advance directive. Written documents provide a clear and legally recognized statement of the patient's wishes, reducing ambiguity and the potential for misinterpretation.

Step-by-step explanation:

When considering whether a patient's directly stated wishes to their physician carry more or less weight than a written document, these verbal statements are generally seen as having less weight than a written directive such as a living will or advance directive. In a legal context, a written document that details a person's medical treatment preferences, like a living will or a DNR order, typically provides a clear, legally recognized expression of the patient's wishes. These documents are particularly important if the patient becomes unable to communicate their desires due to their medical condition.

Verbal instructions may be subject to interpretation or memory recall issues, whereas a written document provides a definitive guide for healthcare providers. In situations where these written instructions exist, they take precedence over verbal statements. This protocol ensures that a patient's previously documented wishes are respected and followed through, even if they can no longer participate in decision-making.