162 views
5 votes
The range of duties and responsibilities for practitioners is as diverse as the publics it deals with.

A) True
B) False

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The range of duties for practitioners is true to be as diverse as the publics they deal with. Dillon's Rule actually restricts local governments by limiting their powers to those explicitly granted by the state. The differences between domestic and foreign policymaking, the duration of sole executive agreements compared to treaties, and the role of women during wartime are also notable points of governance discussions.

Step-by-step explanation:

The statement 'The range of duties and responsibilities for practitioners is as diverse as the publics it deals with.' is True. Practitioners in various fields interact with a broad spectrum of individuals, groups, and communities, each with its own unique needs and challenges. This diversity necessitates a wide range of duties and responsibilities to effectively serve these differing publics. For instance, Dillon's Rule, which is false in suggesting local governments have autonomy, actually limits local governance by stating that any authority granted to them is derived from the state government.

In scenarios where practitioners must adhere to the restrictions of Dillon's Rule while trying to meet the varied demands of their publics, it can lead to conflicts between their responsibilities to adhere to legal frameworks and their duty to serve their community's needs efficiently and effectively. For example, if a locality identifies an emerging community need but state law does not explicitly grant the local government the power to act in that specific area, the responsibility to comply with Dillon's Rule may conflict with the duty to address that need.

Domestic vs. Foreign Policymaking

Two key differences between domestic and foreign policymaking are that domestic policy is often more directly influenced by the concerns and needs of the nation's citizens, whereas foreign policy must navigate international laws and interact with other sovereign states. Furthermore, the processes and governmental structures involved in creating and enforcing these policies are distinct.

Sole executive agreements and treaties represent another aspect of governance. The statement that a sole executive agreement is likely to be in effect longer than a treaty is False. Treaties are formal, ratified agreements that generally have longer durations and more stability compared to executive agreements, which can be more easily altered or terminated by subsequent administrations.

Turning to the role of women during wartime, the assertion that 'Many women found themselves incapable of handling the burdens of war when their husbands and fathers went off to fight' is False. It overlooks the significant contributions and resilience of women who frequently took on a variety of roles at home and in the workforce during times of conflict.

The necessary and proper clause, unlike the suggestion in Exercise 9.3.1, has not limited but expanded the power of the national government by enabling Congress to pass laws deemed necessary and proper for carrying out its enumerated powers.

User Genxgeek
by
8.0k points