175k views
2 votes
Vals is a botanist early experiments with hybridization built in consistently added to collected knowledge, leading straight to Gregor Mendel's later discoveries about genetic inheritance. Why is this conclusion not entirely correct?

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The conclusion that Vals' hybridization experiments led directly to Mendel's discoveries is not entirely accurate because Mendel's research was unique, focusing on discontinuous variation and the clear transmission of traits. Mendel's work, which demonstrated dominant and recessive patterns of inheritance, went largely unnoticed until after his lifetime and only gained recognition in the 20th century.

Step-by-step explanation:

Validity of the Conclusion Linking Vals' Experiments to Mendel's Discoveries

The conclusion that early experiments with hybridization by an unidentified botanist named Vals directly led to Gregor Mendel's later discoveries about genetic inheritance is not entirely correct because this assertion suggests a straightforward progression of scientific knowledge that discounts the complex nature of scientific advancements and the unique contribution of Mendel’s work. While cross-pollination does produce hybrids, the specifics of genetic inheritance were profoundly clarified through Mendel's meticulous experiments with pea plants. Mendel's work was notably different in that he focused on discontinuous variation, choosing traits that were inherited in distinct classes, such as violet versus white flowers, allowing him to observe the clear-cut transmission of traits, rather than a blending of traits.

Mendel's findings went largely unnoticed by the scientific community at the time as many scientists believed in the blending theory. His experiments demonstrated that traits are transmitted from parents to offspring in dominant and recessive patterns, independently of other traits. Mendel’s work laid the foundation for modern genetics, and it was only after the turn of the 20th century, that his experiments were rediscovered and recognized as the basis of inheritance patterns.

User MASL
by
7.4k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.