187k views
1 vote
When Alexander entered Egypt, what mysterious event occurred at the Oracle of Ammon in the oasis of Siwah? What's your opinion about what really happened?

User Ttrasn
by
7.5k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

During Alexander the Great's visit to the Oracle of Ammon in Siwah Oasis in 332 BCE, it is traditionally held that the oracle confirmed him as a divine figure. However, the exact nature of this event is shrouded in mystery, with speculation that historical accounts may have been manipulated for political ends. Many historians consider the truth of what occurred to be elusive, with the divine endorsement possibly overstated to solidify Alexander's authority and legitimacy.

Step-by-step explanation:

The Mysterious Event at the Oracle of Ammon

When Alexander the Great entered Egypt in 332 BCE, he was welcomed as a liberator from Persian rule. A significant, though mysterious, event occurred during his visit to the Oracle of Ammon at the Siwah Oasis. This oracle was considered immensely important, revered by both Egyptians and Greeks, who identified Ammon with Zeus. The details of what transpired during Alexander's consultation with the oracle remain elusive, due in large part to historical accounts being based on the narratives of Alexander's own propagandists, which could have been exaggerated or skewed for political purposes.

According to the traditional story celebrated by Alexander's followers, the oracle confirmed Alexander as not just a king but a divine being, the son of Zeus-Ammon. This affirmation would have solidified his standing in Egypt and bolstered his legitimacy across his empire. However, the exact words spoken by the oracle have not survived, and we are left to speculate on whether this encounter was embellished by Alexander's chroniclers. Debate continues among historians and scholars regarding the factual accuracy of this meeting. Some suggest that the story was contrived for political gain, leveraging the credibility and mystique associated with oracles to elevate Alexander's status.

In our opinion on what really happened, it is crucial to consider the historical context. Given the political advantage that divine endorsement would have provided, it is plausible that the interaction at the Oracle of Ammon was manipulated or at least presented in a way to support Alexander's imperial image. While we may never know the full truth, the event undoubtedly played a key role in how Alexander was viewed by his contemporaries and by history.

User Inxilpro
by
8.8k points