191k views
5 votes
Ahmad came across a small pond and wanted to do wudu. However, he saw a dead fish floating on the surface. Can he do wudu from this water? Explain your reasoning.

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The validity of wudu from a pond with a dead fish present depends on whether the fish has altered the taste, color, or smell of the water.

If it has not, the water may still be used for wudu. If there is doubt or noticeable changes, one should seek further religious guidance.

Step-by-step explanation:

The validity of wudu using water from a pond with a dead fish can be a complex issue and often depends on Islamic jurisprudence interpretations.

According to many Islamic scholars, the presence of the dead animal would not necessarily render the water impure unless it changes one or more of the following characteristics of the water: its taste, color, or smell.

Therefore, if the dead fish has not altered these characteristics of the water in the pond, Ahmad may be able perform wudu with it.

However, if the water does have noticeable changes in taste, color, or smell due to the dead fish, it would be considered impure and not suitable for wudu. As always, when in doubt, it is advisable to seek guidance from a knowledgeable religious authority.

No, Ahmad cannot perform wudu with the water from the small pond if there is a dead fish floating on the surface. According to Islamic jurisprudence, water used for wudu must be pure and clean.

The presence of a dead animal, such as the dead fish, contaminates the water and makes it impure. Therefore, Ahmad should look for another water source to perform wudu.

User Samridhgupta
by
7.9k points