Final answer:
Jack is in charge of punishment in his camp and is likened to a 'king in his dominions,' indicating his absolute power in administering punishment. Privation of food and the 'blackhole' are considered 'childish punishments' because they are less severe, while whipping signifies a more authoritarian rule.
Step-by-step explanation:
In Jack's camp, from the novel 'Lord of the Flies', Jack himself is in charge of punishment. The author later refers to the superintendent of the mines as 'a king in his dominions' which likely signifies the level of absolute power and control the superintendent holds, similar to a monarch ruling their kingdom. This absolute power could extend to enforcing rules, administering punishment, and overseeing productivity within the mines.
As for the comparison between punishments, the privation of food and confinement in a 'black hole' might be seen as 'childish punishments' because they are less severe and perhaps more reminiscent of tactics used to discipline children, rather than serious penalties for grown-ups.
Whipping, on the other hand, is considered a more extreme form of punishment associated with significant pain and physical harm. This more severe method of punishment reflects the harsher, more authoritarian rule that might be employed by the superintendent, who is described metaphorically as king-like in their authority.