Question

Compare the student text with the source.

Source: Paul Glastris, "Why a Second Progressive Era Is Emerging-and How Not to Blow It."
Published in Washington Monthly, 2015:
As many observers have noted, there are arresting parallels between our age
and the 1890s, the dawn of the Progressive Era. Then as now, vast numbers of
Americans found themselves left behind economically.
Student text:
In Glastris's view, the financial struggle of Americans during the Progressive Era
is very similar to the struggle many Americans are experiencing today.
Is the student text plagiarized?
No, it is not plagiarized.
Yes, because it fails to use quotation marks. Is it plagiarized

Answer 1

The student text in question is not plagiarized, as it paraphrases the source rather than copying it verbatim. However, proper citation to the original author, Paul Glastris, is necessary to maintain academic integrity and attribution.

Step-by-step explanation:

The student text is not considered plagiarized because it does not copy the source word for word, but instead paraphrases the main idea, suggesting an understanding of the original material. Although the student has effectively summarized the comparison between the financial struggles during the Progressive Era and contemporary times, it's critical to provide proper citation. In academic writing, paraphrasing must be accompanied by an appropriate reference to the original source. Thus, the paraphrasing should include credit to the author, Paul Glastris. This step ensures there is no ambiguity about the original creator of the compared ideas and maintains academic integrity.

Addressing the broader issue of quoting vs. paraphrasing, it is important to be strategic about including quotations and ensuring that your own voice as a writer is not drowned out by other sources. The goal is to achieve a balance where quotations are integrated within one's own analysis and explanation. If a passage is paraphrased, as in the student example, it is critical to still provide attribution, even without direct quotations.