168k views
1 vote
the Senate "cools" legislation from the House like a _________ ________. Create a simple illustration for your analogy. Finally, list at least two important differences between the House and the Senate that might allow the Senate to "cool" legislation from the House.

User Rji Rji
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The Senate's function to 'cool' legislation from the House is akin to a saucer cooling hot coffee, an analogy reflecting the Senate's role in providing deliberation and temperance to legislative processes with longer six-year terms and individual powers to prolong debate.

Step-by-step explanation:

The simile of the Senate "cooling" legislation from the House likens it to a saucer cooling hot coffee. This reflects the Founders' intent for the Senate to temper hasty legislation with more deliberation and compromise. Two key differences between the House and Senate enable this cooling effect. First, Senators have longer six-year terms, allowing distance from immediate constituent pressures. Second, the Senate's rules permit individual senators to extend debate (or use mechanisms like the filibuster), slowing the legislative process. In contrast, the House's actions reflect more direct constituent demands with rapid movement on bills due to shorter two-year terms and a more stringent structure.

An analogy illustration: A steaming cup labeled 'House' pouring into a saucer labeled 'Senate' with steam dissipating, signifying the modification or halting of bills. The Buffett Rule and the original version of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) serve as historical examples of the Senate slowing or modifying legislation from the House.

Finally, the 'advice and consent' powers of the Senate, differing term lengths, and the broader state-wide constituency of senators provide a structural basis for their ability to moderate legislation from the more rapidly responsive House of Representatives.

User Kelsey Abreu
by
7.4k points