Final answer:
Without additional context or identification of the source material for the character Eddie and the islanders' decision, it is not possible to provide the correct answer.
Step-by-step explanation:
The question seems to refer to a specific situation involving a character named Eddie and the collective decision by islanders regarding his punishment. Without context such as the title of the book, story, or case study, it is impossible to provide an accurate answer. This question likely pertains to a particular narrative or scenario, possibly from a work of fiction, a historical event, or a social studies case. The nature of the question does not narrow it down to any single academic discipline with certainty, nor does it indicate the specific educational grade level.