Question

Craig has made a pledge to always tell the utmost, absolute truth in all situations. he never deceives or tricks anyone and goes out of his way to give full and complete answers to any question someone asks him, even when it hurts someone’s feelings or when a lie would help more people. what is the best description of craig’s behavior?

a. it’s based on an american value, but it’s far outside cultural norms.
b. it’s based on an american norm, but it’s outside of american values.
c. it’s both normal and valued in american to tell the absolute truth in all situations.
d. it’s not normal, and it doesn’t reflect any american values.

Answer 1

Craig's behavior is based on American values, but telling the absolute truth at all times is far outside cultural norms, reflecting a complex moral decision-making process and understanding that sometimes honesty must be tempered with consideration for others' well-being.

Step-by-step explanation:

The best description of Craig’s behavior, where he pledges to always tell the absolute truth regardless of the outcome, would be that it’s based on an American value, but it’s far outside cultural norms. While Americans do value honesty, the societal norms recognize that there are times when being too forthright can be harmful or inappropriate. In balancing conflicting duties such as to never tell a lie and to avoid harming someone, one must consider the potential consequences of absolute truth-telling in every situation. An inherent part of morality is recognizing when the absolute application of one value might conflict with another important value, such as kindness or protecting others from harm. Cultural norms often dictate a more pragmatic approach to truth-telling where honesty is balanced against other considerations. Moreover, the discussion regarding governmental honesty suggests that there is an expectation for governments to behave truthfully, because good citizens and good governments do not habitually lie.