219k views
1 vote
Would you attribute the following behavior to dispositional or situational causes? Justify. Thomas is always falling asleep in math class, but stays wide awake in every one of his other classes.

User Proxpero
by
8.3k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Thomas's tendency to fall asleep in math class appears to be influenced by situational factors specific to that environment, as he does not display the same behavior in other classes. This aligns with the concept of situational influences on behavior and highlights the common mistake of the fundamental attribution error that observers make when explaining the behaviors of others.

Step-by-step explanation:

Thomas's behavior of falling asleep in math class but staying alert in other classes tends to suggest situational influences on behavior. When trying to understand why Thomas exhibits this particular behavior only during math class, it's essential to consider the situational factors that might be contributing to his drowsiness, such as a warm classroom, unengaging teaching methods, or a lack of interest in the subject itself.

However, dispositional factors such as Thomas's own sleep patterns or potential disinterest in math cannot be completely discounted without further information. Nonetheless, the fact that this behavior is exclusive to the math class points more toward situational causes.

The tendency to overlook such situational causes and instead attribute behavior to dispositional factors is known as the fundamental attribution error. Observers often do not have all the information needed to provide a situational explanation for someone's behavior but when it comes to ourselves, we frequently have more context and thus, tend to provide situational explanations for our own behaviors. Understanding this bias can help in more accurately interpreting Thomas's behavior in math class.

User Thetrystero
by
7.5k points